September 1, 2000


PROP 38

PROS & CONS

The Attorney General of California prepared the following title and summary of the proposed measure (PROP 38)

School Vouchers: State-Funded Private and Religious Education. Public School Funding. Initiative Constitutional Amendment.

Authorizes annual state payments of at least $4,000 per pupil for qualifying private and religious schools as grants for new enrollees. Expand eligibility in phases: by fourth year, all children enrolled in qualifying schools are eligible. Permits Legislature to replace current Constitutional funding priority and Proposition 98 guarantees for public schools with new minimum per-public school funding at no less that national average. Restricts regulation of private schools. Exempts private schools from designated Uniform Building Code requirements. Requires academic testing in grant redeeming schools. Summary of estimate by Legislative Analyst and Director of Finance of fiscal impact on state and local governments: This measure would result in a major rearrangement of the State's system of school finance, with growing annual savings in public school expenditures and growing annual costs of a new system of grants for children transferring to, or already attending private schools. Initial fiscal impact ranging from annual costs of over $150 to over $600 million. Long-run fiscal impact ranging from net annual costs to over $500 million to net annual savings of around $2.5 billion. Other fiscal effects include: (1) Potentially significant savings to the State from reduced teacher retirement contribution; (2) unknown, potentially significant, savings to the State and local school districts from reduced capital outlay needs; and (3) unknown potential loss of federal education funds to the state.

Supporting :

Carmela & Rigo Garnica founders of `Escuela de La Raza Unida. School founded 28 years ago to save Hispanic children of farm worker families from blatant discrimination in the public school system.

Acampichtli J.M. Garcia Castillo, Director of the Cultural Council of YUANKUIKKANAHUAK (Nuevo anahuatl), Cultural organization with the National Institute of Anthropology and History of Mexico.

Alfredo Figueroa forty years organizer with AWOC, UFW, MAPA, HMN, and president and founder of La Escuala de La Raza Unida (ERU).

La Prensa San Diego, founded 25 years ago. Publisher supports parents having a choice available to rescue our children from the continued failure of public education to educate our children and condemning them to a life of ignorance, poverty, & early death.

Opposing:

The San Diego Union

Republican Legislators; Charlene Zettel, Anthony Pescetti, Jim Cuneen, Abel Maldonado, Bruce McPherson.

(La Prensa will continue its scoreboard on PROP 38 as they come in to our offices. Send your opinions in on this vital educational issue)

Comments? Return to the Frontpage